Amish Photographs: Respect, Culture & What Every Traveler Should Know

If you’re like me, when you travel you want to capture everything. The rolling hills, the roadside markets, the quirky little barns—and yes, the people who make the place unique. But when it comes to the Amish communities in the Finger Lakes, photography isn’t just a casual thing. It’s a sensitive cultural issue.

The Amish live by traditions that date back centuries, and their relationship with technology—including cameras—is cautious at best. While snapping a photo of a pie stand or horse-drawn buggy may seem harmless, photographing Amish people directly can cross boundaries.

That’s why this article exists—to help you understand the do’s and don’ts of photographing Amish life in the Finger Lakes, so you can travel respectfully while still capturing memories.

---

2. Understanding Amish Beliefs About Photos

The Amish believe that photographs of people can encourage pride or vanity, which conflicts with their values of humility and modesty. Some also view photography as a graven image, something to be avoided for religious reasons.

Here are a few key points:

• Direct Portraits Are Discouraged: Taking a clear, posed photo of an Amish person is generally not acceptable.

• Unaware Photos Are Still Problematic: Even candid shots can feel invasive if someone realizes they’ve been photographed.

• Focus on What’s Permitted: It’s usually fine to take photos of landscapes, markets (from a respectful distance), buggies, barns, and goods for sale.

Think of it this way: you’re not being told not to photograph—you’re being invited to shift your focus toward the parts of Amish life that are okay to share.

👉 If you want the full cultural background of the Amish communities here, I recommend my pillar guide: Amish Finger Lakes New York: Markets, Culture & Scenic Trails. This article zooms in on the photography side of things.

3. The Finger Lakes Amish Communities: What Makes Them Unique

While Amish communities exist in several U.S. states, the Finger Lakes Amish have their own charm. Towns like Penn Yan, Dundee, Branchport, and Romulus are home to Amish families who balance farm work, markets, and craft traditions.

Here’s what makes this region special for photographers:

• Landscape Contrast: Rolling vineyards and lakes sit alongside Amish barns and fields.

• Seasonal Beauty: Snow-dusted buggies in winter, golden cornfields in summer, apple orchards in fall.

• Accessible Markets: The roadside stands make it easy to experience Amish culture without intruding.

Explore main Amish Areas on google maps

This mix of Amish tradition and Finger Lakes scenery gives you endless opportunities for photography—if you know what’s appropriate to capture.

---

4. Do’s of Photographing in Amish Country

Let’s start with the positives—things you can and should photograph when visiting Amish country in the Finger Lakes.

• ✅ Do Photograph Scenery: Barns, buggies on the road, quilts hanging on lines, roadside stands.

• ✅ Do Capture Goods for Sale: Pies, breads, crafts, and preserves displayed at markets.

• ✅ Do Focus on Atmosphere: Markets buzzing with life, autumn pumpkins, or snow-covered farmlands.

• ✅ Do Ask Politely (if unsure): If you’re tempted to take a photo near a stand, a simple, respectful ask goes a long way.

💡 Example: Instead of aiming your camera at a family in their buggy, step back and photograph the buggy rolling down the scenic road with fields and hills in the background. The story is still there, but the focus is on the experience, not individuals.

5. Don’ts of Photographing in Amish Country

Now that we’ve covered what you can do, let’s talk about what you shouldn’t do. These are the common mistakes visitors make—sometimes out of curiosity, sometimes out of excitement.

• ❌ Don’t Photograph Faces: Avoid close-up shots of Amish individuals, especially children. For them, it’s not just about privacy—it’s tied to deep cultural beliefs.

• ❌ Don’t Sneak Photos: Taking hidden or long-lens shots of Amish families may feel less intrusive to you, but it can come across as disrespectful.

• ❌ Don’t Pose Amish People: Unlike other travel spots where locals might happily pose, Amish people do not. Don’t ask them to stand for portraits.

• ❌ Don’t Use Drones Near Amish Farms: Beyond being disruptive, drones feel invasive. Stick to traditional photography.

• ❌ Don’t Treat Amish Communities as Tourist Displays: Remember that Amish people are not “attractions.” They’re families going about their lives.

💡 Personal Note: I once saw a visitor snap a candid of an Amish child near Dundee. The discomfort on the parents’ faces was immediate. It was a reminder to me—and now to you—that respect comes before the perfect shot.

---

6. Respectful Alternatives to Direct Photography

Okay, so you can’t photograph Amish people directly. But that doesn’t mean you can’t capture the essence of Amish country. Here’s how:

🌾 1. Focus on Landscapes

Photograph the barns, fields, and roads where buggies travel. Often, these shots are even more beautiful because they tell the story without needing faces.

🥧 2. Highlight the Goods

Pies, breads, crafts, and roadside produce look incredible in photos. A simple basket of apples can say just as much about Amish life as a portrait.

🐴 3. Capture Motion from Afar

A buggy rolling along a country road looks stunning from a distance—especially with Finger Lakes hills or vineyards in the background.

🪟 4. Frame the Atmosphere

Instead of focusing on individuals, take wide-angle shots of markets, fields during harvest, or quilts on lines.

📓 5. Mix Photography with Journaling

Sometimes, words capture what photos cannot. Jot down the story behind a pie stand, the smell of fresh bread, or the sound of horseshoes on the road. Pair these notes with landscape shots for a travel journal that feels full.

---

📊 Quick Reference: Do’s & Don’ts of Photographing Amish Finger Lakes