Amish Finger Lakes New York. : Your Travel Guide

1. Where Are the Amish in Finger Lakes, New York?

The Amish Finger Lakes New York communities are mostly found in the region’s western and central areas. These locations include parts of Seneca, Yates, and Steuben counties. Their farms and businesses are often located on quiet rural roads, nestled among rolling hills and open fields.

Unlike major tourist towns, Amish communities are usually unmarked on typical tourist maps. That’s why a local guide or Google Maps search helps a lot. You can use this Google Maps link to spot markets and known Amish shops.

Some of the largest Amish settlements near Finger Lakes include:

Penn Yan (Yates County): A central hub with a strong Amish presence.
Dundee: A town where you’ll find Amish farms and quilt shops.
Naples and Branchport: Known for handmade furniture and baked goods.
Romulus and Ovid: Small settlements with farm stands and local goods.

These towns offer an authentic look at Amish life. You’ll often see horse-drawn buggies and farms without electric lines. The best way to explore? Drive slowly, stop by open roadside stands, and enjoy the peace.

2.Top Amish Finger Lakes New York Towns to Visit

When exploring Amish Finger Lakes New York, some towns stand out. Each offers its own charm and unique mix of Amish culture and rural beauty.

Penn Yan

Penn Yan, located in Yates County, is surrounded by scenic farmland. It’s one of the most recognized towns for Amish visitors. The roads here are lined with signs for handcrafted furniture, quilt shops, and seasonal produce.

Highlight: Windmill Farm & Craft Market, open Saturdays
Scenic Drive: Follow Route 14A for the best Amish stops

Dundee

A smaller town just south of Penn Yan, Dundee is known for leather goods and home-baked pies. Local Amish families run seasonal farm stands with eggs, butter, and jams.

Tip: Look for small wooden signs—Amish don’t advertise with neon
Event: The annual craft fair in Dundee often features Amish goods

Branchport & Naples

Located on the western edge of Keuka Lake, these towns are dotted with Amish woodworking shops. You’ll also find handwoven baskets and old-fashioned toys.

These towns are not commercialized, which means your experience feels personal and peaceful. Plus, the drives between them offer breathtaking views of the Finger Lakes’ natural beauty.

3. Best Amish Markets in Finger Lakes New York

You can’t talk about the Amish Finger Lakes New York scene without mentioning markets. These are more than just shopping trips—they’re full experiences. You can sample food, buy handmade goods, and talk with locals.

The Windmill Farm & Craft Market (Penn Yan)

This is the largest market in the area featuring dozens of Amish and Mennonite vendors.

Open: Saturdays from April through November
What to Buy: Baked goods, cheeses, preserves, leather belts, wood toys
Atmosphere: Lively but respectful of Amish simplicity

Visit Windmill Farm Market

Seneca Produce Auction (Romulus)

While not a traditional market, this wholesale auction is where Amish farmers sell in bulk. Visitors are welcome, and it offers a rare behind-the-scenes look.

Open to Public: Certain days—check local listings
Best For: Bulk buyers, produce lovers, farm-to-table restaurant owners

Other Roadside Markets

Throughout Amish towns like Branchport, you’ll find handmade roadside signs that say things like “Eggs,” “Quilts,” or “Fresh Pies.” These stands are unstaffed or run by family members and operate on an honor system.

Tip: Carry cash—Amish vendors rarely take cards
Bonus: Products are seasonal and often organic

4. What to Buy from Amish in Finger Lakes New York

One of the biggest attractions in Amish Finger Lakes New York is the craftsmanship. Amish goods are known for their durability, simplicity, and handmade beauty.

What to Look For:

Quilts: These take weeks to make and often feature traditional patterns.
Furniture: Solid oak tables, rocking chairs, and hand-carved headboards.
Leather Goods: Belts, wallets, horse harnesses, and handbags.
Wooden Toys: Non-electric, old-fashioned, and kid-safe.
Soaps & Candles: Often made with goat milk and beeswax.

These items are usually sold directly from the artisan’s home or at small markets. Each product reflects the values of the Amish community: quality, honesty, and hard work.

When you buy directly, you support the family and get a story to take home.

5. Best Time to Explore Amish Country in Finger Lakes

Timing matters when visiting Amish Finger Lakes New York. The Amish lifestyle follows the seasons closely, and that impacts what you’ll see and experience.

Spring (April–May)

Fields come to life. Farm stands reopen. You’ll find seedlings, early vegetables, and baked goods. Saturdays at the Windmill Market are especially good.

Summer (June–August)

This is the peak time. Markets are full, produce is abundant, and handcrafted items are available everywhere. Expect horse-drawn buggies on every country road.

Fall (September–October)

Crisp air and fall colors make this the most scenic time. Apple cider, homemade pies, and pumpkins are in full supply.

Winter (November–March)

Some markets close, but a few stands stay open with root veggies and canned goods. It’s also when you’ll find handmade winter quilts.

6. Amish Food & Baked Goods in Finger Lakes New York

If you’re visiting Amish Finger Lakes New York, you can’t miss the homemade food. Amish cooking is rooted in tradition, using simple ingredients and time-honored recipes passed down through generations.

What to Try:

Shoofly Pie: A molasses-based dessert with a rich, gooey texture.
Whoopie Pies: Cream-filled chocolate cakes loved by kids and adults alike.
Homemade Breads: White, wheat, and specialty loaves baked in wood ovens.
Canned Goods: Pickles, jams, apple butter, and relishes.
Egg Noodles and Pasta: Often hand-rolled and sun-dried.
Soft Pretzels: Warm, buttery, and perfect for on-the-go snacks.

Many Amish homes sell baked goods from small shops on their property. Look for wooden signs at the end of driveways reading “Fresh Bread Today” or “Pies for Sale.” These stands work on the honor system, so bring small bills and change.

Some of the best baked goods can be found at:

The Windmill Farm Market
Seneca Produce Auction
Dundee roadside stands

The flavor, freshness, and care in every bite reflect the values of the community. It’s not just food—it’s a taste of Amish life.

7. Visitor Etiquette in Amish Finger Lakes New York

When exploring Amish Finger Lakes New York, respect is key. The Amish way of life is deeply rooted in humility, modesty, and tradition. While they’re welcoming, there are unspoken rules every visitor should follow.

Key Etiquette Tips:

Don’t Take Photos: Amish people avoid photography due to religious beliefs. Always ask before pointing a camera.
Dress Respectfully: Simple clothing is best—avoid flashy outfits.
Drive Cautiously: Share the road with horse-drawn buggies. Pass slowly and never honk.
Be Polite: Greet with a smile, don’t intrude on private property, and keep noise down.
Respect Their Time: Sundays are a day of rest. Most shops and markets are closed.
Cash is King: No credit cards or Venmo here—carry cash, preferably small bills.

Remember, you’re stepping into a different world. The best way to experience it? Listen, observe, and appreciate the quiet wisdom behind their lifestyle.

8. Scenic Drives Through Amish Country in Finger Lakes

Driving through Amish Finger Lakes New York offers peaceful scenery and hidden gems. You’ll see open fields, red barns, and roadside stands packed with fresh goods and crafts.

Top Driving Routes:

Route 14A (Between Penn Yan and Dundee): A straight stretch lined with farmhouses, fields, and signs for quilts and produce.
County Route 36 (Naples to Prattsburgh): Winding roads through hills and valleys, perfect for fall foliage drives.
West Bluff Drive (Near Keuka Lake): Offers lake views plus the occasional Amish roadside shop.

What You’ll See Along the Way:

Horse-drawn buggies trotting beside cars
Laundry drying on lines stretched between trees
Wooden produce stands shaded by maple trees
Homemade furniture displayed on porches

Roll down the windows, drive slowly, and stop whenever something catches your eye. Many of the best experiences are spontaneous.

View these routes on Google Maps

9. Where to Stay Near Amish Finger Lakes New York

If you’re planning more than a day trip, consider staying near the Amish communities. Accommodations range from rustic inns to charming bed and breakfasts, each offering a peaceful atmosphere.

Recommended Stays:

Los Gatos Bed & Breakfast (Penn Yan): Near many Amish shops and markets. Cozy and locally owned.
Finger Lakes Farmhouse (Dundee): A country-style inn surrounded by farmland and just minutes from Amish stands.
Black Sheep Inn (Hammondsport): Offers eco-conscious lodging and is close to Amish leather and wood shops.

Staying in or near Amish country lets you explore at your own pace. Plus, morning walks offer sights like fog-covered fields and the clip-clop of early buggy rides.

Check Airbnb and local inn directories for listings close to Amish Finger Lakes New York zones.

10.Local Events Featuring Amish Crafts and Culture

Amish don’t host flashy festivals, but their work is often featured in regional events and craft shows. These events are perfect places to see high-quality goods and connect with the makers.

Annual Events to Watch For:

The Windmill Craft Festival (Penn Yan): Late spring and fall—features many Amish and Mennonite vendors.
Naples Grape Festival: While not Amish-run, local vendors often sell handmade Amish quilts and furniture.
Keuka Arts Festival: A blend of art and tradition with Amish influences.

These events combine culture, creativity, and community spirit. Bring cash, a large tote bag, and your curiosity. You’ll leave with more than just souvenirs—you’ll take home a story.

11. How to Support Amish Businesses in Finger Lakes

Supporting Amish Finger Lakes New York businesses is rewarding—for you and them. But it’s important to do it the right way.

Do:

Buy Direct: Stop at roadside stands or visit homes with open shops.
Use Cash: Small denominations are best.
Be Patient: Amish don’t rush transactions. Enjoy the slower pace.
Respect Boundaries: Don’t wander into barns or private areas.
Say Thank You: A simple smile or polite goodbye is always appreciated.

Don’t:

Haggle: Prices are set based on time and effort.
Ask to Take Photos: It’s against their religious beliefs.
Treat It Like a Museum: This is their home and livelihood.

Your purchase supports a family, not a corporation. And the goods? They’re made with care, skill, and a deep sense of tradition.

12. Photography Rules in Amish Finger Lakes New York

One of the most common questions about Amish Finger Lakes New York is whether photography is allowed. The short answer? Not really.

Here’s What to Know:

No Portraits: Amish beliefs prohibit posed photography of people.
Landscape Only: Photos of barns, fields, and roads are okay—just avoid capturing people.
Always Ask: If you’re unsure, it’s best to politely ask for permission.
Discreet Gear: Leave the big camera lenses at home. Use your phone sparingly.

Why This Matters:

The Amish value humility. Being photographed may be seen as a form of vanity. They prefer privacy and modesty. Respecting this helps build trust between visitors and locals.

If you want visuals to remember the trip, focus on their beautiful surroundings—rolling hills, horse-drawn buggies, or handmade signs.

13. Top Amish Farm Stands in Finger Lakes New York

In Amish Finger Lakes New York, the farm stand is more than a place to shop—it’s a community tradition.

Top Farm Stands to Check Out:

Yoder’s Produce Stand (Dundee): Fresh veggies, flowers, and Amish jams.
Miller’s Bakery (Near Penn Yan): Famous for warm breads, cinnamon rolls, and pies.
Esh’s Variety (Branchport): A roadside treasure offering handmade toys, eggs, butter, and crafts.

Look for:

Wooden signs with simple lettering
Coolers or baskets set up on benches
Metal cash boxes or envelopes for payment

Visiting farm stands gives you fresh, local food with zero packaging or middlemen. It’s pure, simple, and delicious.

14. Cultural Influence of Amish on Finger Lakes Region

The Amish bring more than products—they shape the culture of Finger Lakes New York in subtle but lasting ways.

Their Impact Includes:

Architecture: Simple barns and houses influence local building styles.
Craftsmanship: Even non-Amish builders follow Amish techniques.
Food Culture: Farmer’s markets are inspired by Amish self-sufficiency.
Traffic Etiquette: Buggies change how roads are used and respected.

Many non-Amish residents admire the values of their Amish neighbors. Ideas like working hard, living simply, and prioritizing family life have quietly shaped the tone of the region.

This blend of old and new makes the Finger Lakes feel grounded, timeless, and rich with meaning.

15. Conclusion: Planning Your Amish Finger Lakes New York Trip

Exploring Amish Finger Lakes New York is about more than sightseeing. It’s about connecting with a way of life that’s rooted in simplicity, community, and deep craftsmanship. Whether you’re buying quilts, tasting fresh pies, or admiring hand-built furniture, each experience tells a story.

Final Travel Tips:

Go Slow: Drive gently, especially near buggies.
Respect Privacy: No photos of people.
Bring Cash: Credit cards won’t help you at a roadside pie stand.
Follow the Signs: Some of the best stops are unlisted.
Be Curious: Ask questions kindly, and you’ll learn a lot.

Take a break from digital life and step into the quiet rhythm of Amish country. The peace you’ll find in the Finger Lakes isn’t just in the scenery—it’s in the way people live.

FAQs

1. Where can I find Amish communities in Finger Lakes, New York?

Look in towns like Penn Yan, Dundee, Branchport, and Romulus.

2. Do Amish people sell goods directly to visitors?

Yes, many run farm stands, markets, and home shops that welcome respectful guests.

3. Can I take pictures of Amish people or their property?

No. Respect their beliefs and avoid taking photos of people or close to their homes.

4. What’s the best season to visit Amish Finger Lakes areas?

Summer and fall offer the best selection of produce, crafts, and scenery.

5. How can I support Amish businesses?

Buy handmade goods directly, pay with cash, and respect their way of life.

Exploring the Amish in Finger Lakes, New York: Markets, Culture & Scenic Trails

Table of Contents